Saturday, January 25, 2020

Jefferson County’s Orphan Train Children, 1911


By Donna Ward

Look back in time to the week of January 13, 1911. The lives of some of our citizens are scored by that date. That week, the people of Oskaloosa were discussing “The Orphans” who were coming from New York. Sentiments were divided on the topic of these children. Men and women whose empty homes had been denied children were anxiously waiting, daring to hope that their dreams would come true and a child be theirs to keep. Prophets of gloom were denouncing New York Easterners, the government and anything else convenient for dumping the slum-bred problems of New York in Kansas’ clean, clear air. Others were sympathetically considering the alternative fate of children who would grow up into lives of degradation if left on the streets of the big cities. Some people were thinking in terms of gaining an extra pair of hands to help with the never ending farmwork. The majority of people, however, were simply curious; were these waifs different in some way? Who would come and choose?

The Oskaloosa committee had been selected. Anna Laura Hill, the children’s escort, needed their help in placing the little ones in suitable homes. They inserted the following notice in the January 13th issue of the Oskaloosa Independent:
            “Agents of Children’s Aid Society have fifteen children from orphanages of New York State here for distribution this afternoon and evening, after the manner of the late distribution at Valley Falls. The local committee is composed of Drs. McCreight and Smith, D.A. Bliss, W.E. Huddleston, G.N. Jacquemin, S.E. True, J.H. Morrow.”
These men were influential in the community. They were cognizant of the position, temperament, and ability of most of the local residents. By practicing careful selection, the Children’s Aid Society claimed a 90 percent record for permanent placement.

Although many of the children placed by the Children’s Aid Society were adopted, that was not a requirement for placement. Even after the careful screening, Miss Hill returned from time to time to check on the children’s progress, the suitability of their homes and education. Many of the children established close friendships with Miss Hill, and corresponded with her the rest of her life.

The children had traveled on a regular passenger coach. After forty-three hours on the train, they were grimy and disheveled when they arrived. Miss Hill worked with experienced hands to clean them up, scrub their faces, slick down their hair, and brush their clothing. They stepped off that train prepared to face a new life in a new state with new families. To their eyes, the people looked and sounded somewhat strange. The little ones hid their faces, the older boys vacillated between sullen stares and bravado poses, and the girls tried to look calm and pretty while blushing under the stares of the depot spectators.

Miss Hill gathered her group about her, much as a mother would collect her brood. The ride into town on the hack was a pleasant relief from the stuffy coach. She counted out the 25¢ fare and ushered the children into the hotel. In the privacy of the hotel, they attacked the grime of their journey in earnest. The older children helped the younger ones. Miss Hill soothed their nervous jitters and short tempers, and reassured the frightened ones with her calm attendance to duties. After the brief respite, Miss Hill began her conversations with the local citizens. Some families offered temporary housing for some of the children. The youngest child was Friedolf Fredricksen, age two. He ate his first meal in Oskaloosa with the William Payne family. With his blond curls, impish smile, and brave acceptance of what life was offering him, he quickly made friends in his new hometown.


The month before this trainload arrived, a group of children had been placed in Valley Falls. Circulars had been distributed there, but the Oskaloosa Independent of December 9, 1910, had quoted the bulletin in its entirety with a headline “New York Waifs in Jefferson County.” Similar circulars had been posted in the city and passed around the county. Public interest was stirred.

At the appointed hour, the children were seated on the stage of the opera house, and Miss Hill addressed the gathered crowd. As people were attracted to certain children, they were interviewed by the committee, presented their recommendations, and were considered. Those who were chosen to receive a child were given a card with that child’s history on it. They entered an agreement to provide proper care, education, and reports to the society. The society reserved the right to visit and inspect the home within a year, and to remove the child if they found it unsuitable.

Critchfield Opera House stage
Those children that were not placed in Oskaloosa were taken to Valley Falls to fulfill the requests from the earlier distribution. After the excitement, the following item appeared in the January 20th, 1911, issue of the Oskaloosa Independent, in the editorial comments:
            “The New York Orphans All Find Homes
            “The agents in charge of the orphans from New York state orphanages left town yesterday, having found homes for nine of their little charges in Oskaloosa and 6 going to Valley Falls where the former supply did not quite meet the demand, it seems.
            “A great deal of interest in the children was shown here, and several families entertained children until homes were found for them.
            “Legal adoption is not required and the children are really taken on trial, the society agreeing to take the child back if anything goes wrong. They are visited twice during the first year and then annually for a time, and families taking children are required to make yearly reports.
            “The best appearing children, and those in good health, are picked to bring to Western homes.
            “Otto Lantz, who lives 4 miles southeast of Oskaloosa, took a little German boy aged 3½ years, named Samuel Dubar — a bright little chap who speaks German readily.
            “Chas. Winans, at the old Fair grounds, has a little 2 year old German girl, Fredoff Fredericks.*
            “F.H. Corson, at the edge of town on the northwest, takes Katie Fichtner, aged 11.
            “Louis A. Kimmel, a mile east of town, has the oldest two of the lot, Anna Potthoff, aged 15, and William, her brother, aged 13 years.
            “Owen Johnston, 3½ miles northwest of town, has a little 6 year old maiden, Adelaide Loggman.
            “Harvey Wood, who recently came from Missouri and is on the Critchfield farm, 2½ miles southwest of town, has a boy, aged 9, Henry G. Palmer.
            “James Quakenbush, just east of town, takes Eva Grant, aged 10 years.
            “Thomas Davis, on the old Snyder farm, southwest of town, has Mildred Grant aged 12.
            “This lot of youngsters have certainly found good homes, and it is to be hoped will grow into good, strong, bright young men and women.
            “Of those sent to Valley Falls, Norman Deacon, aged 5 goes to Jessie _____; Fred Valentine, aged 6, to Newton Bilger; Wm. Bugglen, 12 years, to A.H. Jurgens; Wm. Hoyt, 8 years, to J. Irvin Spence; Marvin Miller, aged 6, to A.J. Jurgens.
            “The agents say that only about one in ten of the children are ever taken back, nearly all of them being acceptable to the families taking them.”

* “Fredoff’s” name was Friedolf Fredricksen, and he was of masculine gender and of Swedish heritage.

Friedolf Fredricksen was clothed in a dress, the normal attire for baby boys of that period. The Charles Winans family did not have other children, and chose “Friedoff” for their own. Before the end of the same year, they had completed the legal adoption. They considered him their son and never discussed his origins with him. In later years, his mother was unhappy that he tried to find his family.

Samuel Dubar was the 3½ year old German speaking child adopted by the Otto Lantzes. A picture of him in Friedoff’s possession shows a dark haired, delicately formed lad, with a fresh bright smile. The inscription on the picture is, “Otto Frederick Lantz, age 4 years, 1911.” The Lantz parents separated and all contact with the child was lost.

Mr. and Mrs. Kimmel took two of the older children. William was 13, and Anna was 15. Anna died a few years later, according to Friedoff, my informant.

Adelaide Loggman, age 6, was adopted by Mr. and Mrs. Owen Johnston. Of all the children, she was the one who tried to keep contact with the others, and she corresponded with Miss Hill. She clerked in the town stores, tended to the needs of her family, and became the typical old maid in town. Late in life, she married a Mr. Brown, living out of town for four or five years before she died of cancer.

Eva Grant, age 10, was adopted by Mr. and Mrs. James Quakenbush. She married Omer Frazier, the brother of Friedoff’s wife. Eva raised four children, William T., Harold, Doris and Betty.

Eva’s sister, Mildred Grant, was given a home by Mr. and Mrs. Tom Davis. Because of friction in the home, Mildred left while still young. She married a Mr. Harness; they made their home in California.

Anna Laura Hill
Most of the families discouraged the children from looking into the past. It was seldom discussed either with the parents or with each other. However, Mildred and Eva Grant did go back to find their brother, Gus, and sisters with whom they held a close relationship.


This story appeared in “Yesteryears” in October 1981, with an addition in April 1982 and a reprint of the Independent article in April 1995.

No comments:

Post a Comment